Depictions that Deceive: When Historical Fiction Does Harm
This statement serves as a thoughtful and firm response to the release of the controversial streaming series. It highlights important concerns about historical accuracy, the risks of sensationalism, and the harm caused by perpetuating harmful stereotypes. Here’s a breakdown of the key themes presented:
1. Misrepresentation of Historical Figures
The statement underscores how the series portrays Brigham Young—a central figure in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints and an iconic pioneer—in a misleading and harmful way. It asserts that his depiction as “villainous” and “fanatical” not only distorts history but disrespects the legacy of a man revered by millions.
2. Addressing the Mountain Meadows Massacre
Acknowledging the gravity of the Mountain Meadows Massacre, the statement points out the Church’s openness in addressing this dark chapter in its history. It emphasizes:
- The Church’s condemnation of the event.
- Efforts to uncover and share the full truth.
- The commitment to promoting healing and reconciliation.
3. The Dangers of Sensationalized Storytelling
The critique is sharp but measured, pointing out how the series’ dramatized and graphic portrayal:
- Obscures reality.
- Prevents genuine understanding of complex historical contexts.
- Risks fostering animosity, division, and even violence during a time when unity is needed.
4. A Call for Peace
The statement echoes President Russell M. Nelson’s plea for peacemaking and discipleship based on kindness, persuasion, and inspiration. It frames this as a choice everyone can make, regardless of how divisive or challenging a situation might be.
Key Takeaways
While the Church acknowledges and grapples with its history, the statement calls for fairness and accuracy in how historical events and figures are portrayed. It also positions itself firmly in favor of peace and understanding, resonating with values shared across faith traditions.
The overall tone is constructive, urging all people—viewers, creators, and communities alike—to approach sensitive topics with respect and a commitment to truth and healing.
Would you like help drafting a response or summary of this statement for a specific audience?
